How did your MP vote on conscience issues?
Information about Conscience Votes
During the last Parliament, there have been conscience votes on surrogacy and cloning human embryos for destructive research. Both of these questions revolved around the sanctity and value of human life.
Conscience votes are not a comprehensive measure of a politician's values. They are usually only held on sensitive questions of life, and do not apply to other important value matters where politicians usually follow their party's line. Nonetheless, conscience votes do show how a politician approaches a significant ethical question, where their sense of values comes from, and what their personal view is on what we believe to be one of the most important questions of all: the protection of human life from conception to natural death.
EMILY's List
EMILY's List is a political network formed to increase the number of women Labor parliamentarians who are willing to support key feminist issues, including abortion. It provides financial, political and personal support to Labor women candidates who agree to support the values of EMILY's List.
It is the only network of its kind in Australian politics. |
| |
| EMILY's List members and candidates must support the principles of equity, diversity, pro-choice, and the provision of equal pay and childcare, both in the community and in Parliament. Many of these are signficant issues but it is concerning that membership of such a network dictates a parliamentarian's vote. For example, EMILY's List members consistently support pro-abortion policies, reflecting both their personal beliefs and their membership of the List. Without exception, every Federal ALP parliamentarian named on EMILY's List voted to support the abortion drug RU486 and to permit the cloning of human embryos for destructive research. |
 |
| |
| Not all female Labor MPs or Senators are EMILY's List members. Some prominent ALP members such as NSW Senator Ursula Stephens and Tasmanian Senator Helen Polley support pro-life policies. However, if you want to support candidates who recognise the value of human life from its earliest stages then you need to know if your current representative or local candidate is a member of EMILY's List because List membership will determine her vote on these issues. Click here to find out. |
Surrogacy and Cloning - How did your MP vote?
Legislative Assembly| Electorate | Party | MP | Vote on Surrogacy | Vote on Cloning | Notes |
| Albany |
A.L.P. |
Watson, Mr Peter |
Supported surrogacy |
Opposed cloning |
|
| Alfred Cove |
Independent Liberal |
Wollard, Dr Janet |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Armadale |
A.L.P. |
MacTiernan, Hon. Alannah |
No vote recorded |
Supported cloning |
|
| Avon |
National Party |
Trenorden, Mr Max |
Supported surrogacy |
No vote recorded |
|
| Balcatta |
A.L.P. |
Kobelke, Hon. John |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Ballajura |
A.L.P. |
D'Orazio, Mr John |
Opposed surrogacy |
No vote recorded |
|
| Bassendean |
A.L.P. |
Whitely, Mr Martin |
Supported surrogacy |
Opposed cloning |
|
| Belmont |
A.L.P. |
Ripper, Hon. Eric |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Bunbury |
Liberal Party |
Castrilli, Mr John |
No vote recorded |
No vote recorded |
*opposed cloning in third reading |
| Capel |
Liberal Party |
Thomas, Dr Steve |
No vote recorded |
Opposed cloning |
|
| Carine |
Liberal Party |
Hodson-Thomas, Ms Katina |
Opposed surrogacy |
Opposed cloning |
|
| Central Kimberley-Pilbara |
A.L.P. |
Stephens, Hon. Tom |
Opposed surrogacy |
Opposed cloning |
|
| Churchlands |
Independent |
Constable, Dr Elizabeth |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Cockburn |
A.L.P. |
Logan, Hon. Fran |
No vote recorded |
Supported cloning |
|
| Collie-Wellington |
A.L.P. |
Murray, Mr Mick |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Cottesloe |
Liberal Party |
Barnett, Mr Colin |
Supported surrogacy |
No vote recorded |
*supported cloning in third reading |
| Darling Range |
Liberal Party |
Day, Hon. John |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Dawesville |
Liberal Party |
Hames, Hon. Dr Kim |
No vote recorded |
Supported cloning |
|
| Fremantle |
A.L.P. |
McGinty, Hon. Jim |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Geraldton |
A.L.P. |
Hill, Mr Shane |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Girrawheen |
A.L.P. |
Quirk, Hon. Margaret |
Supported surrogacy |
Opposed cloning |
|
| Greenough |
National Party |
Woodhams, Mr Grant |
Supported surrogacy |
No vote recorded |
|
| Hillarys |
Liberal Party |
Johnson, Mr Rob |
Opposed surrogacy |
No vote recorded |
|
| Joondalup |
A.L.P. |
O'Gorman, Mr Tony |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Kalgoorlie |
Liberal Party |
Birney, Mr Matthew |
Opposed surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Kenwick |
A.L.P. |
McHale, Hon. Sheila |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Kimberley |
A.L.P. |
Martin, Ms Carol Anne |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Kingsley |
A.L.P. |
Hughes, Ms Judy |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Leschenault |
Independent |
Barron-Sullivan, Mr Dan |
Opposed surrogacy |
Opposed cloning |
|
| Mandurah |
A.L.P. |
Templeman, Hon. David |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Maylands |
A.L.P. |
Edwards, Hon. Dr Judy |
No vote recorded |
Supported cloning |
|
| Merredin |
National Party |
Grylls, Mr John |
Supported surrogacy |
No vote recorded |
|
| Midland |
A.L.P. |
Roberts, Hon. Michelle |
Supported surrogacy |
No vote recorded |
*opposed cloning in third reading |
| Mindarie |
A.L.P. |
Quigley, Mr John |
Supported surrogacy |
No vote recorded |
*opposed cloning in third reading |
| Moore |
Liberal Party |
Snook, Mr Gary |
No vote recorded |
No vote recorded |
*opposed cloning in third reading |
| Murchison-Eyre |
Independent |
Bowler, Mr John |
No vote recorded |
No vote recorded |
|
| Murdoch |
Liberal Party |
Porter, Mr Christian |
No vote recorded |
No vote recorded |
|
| Murray |
Liberal Party |
Cowper, Mr Murray |
Opposed surrogacy |
Opposed cloning |
|
| Nedlands |
Independent |
Walker, Ms Sue |
Opposed surrogacy |
Opposed cloning |
|
| North West Coastal |
A.L.P. |
Riebeling, Hon. Fred |
No vote recorded |
No vote recorded |
|
| Peel |
A.L.P. |
Papalia, Mr Paul |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Perth |
A.L.P. |
Hyde, Mr John |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Riverton |
A.L.P. |
McRae, Mr Tony |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Rockingham |
A.L.P. |
McGowan, Hon. Mark |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Roe |
Liberal Party |
Jacobs, Dr Graham |
Opposed surrogacy |
Opposed cloning |
|
| Serpentine-Jarrahdale |
Liberal Party |
Simpson, Mr Tony |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| South Perth |
Liberal Party |
McGrath, Mr John |
Opposed surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Southern River |
A.L.P. |
Andrews, Mr Paul |
Supported surrogacy |
No vote recorded |
*opposed cloning in third reading |
| Stirling |
National Party |
Redman, Mr Donald |
Supported surrogacy |
No vote recorded |
|
| Swan Hills |
A.L.P. |
Radisich, Ms Jaye |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Vasse |
Liberal Party |
Buswell, Mr Troy |
Opposed surrogacy |
Opposed cloning |
|
| Victoria Park |
A.L.P. |
Wyatt, Mr Ben |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Wagin |
National Party |
Waldron, Mr Terry |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Wanneroo |
A.L.P. |
Guise, Mrs Diane |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Warren-Blackwood |
Liberal Party |
Omodei, Hon. Paul |
Opposed surrogacy |
No vote recorded |
*opposed cloning in third reading |
| Willagee |
A.L.P. |
Carpenter, Hon. Alan |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
| Yokine |
Independent |
Kucera, Mr Bob |
Supported surrogacy |
Supported cloning |
|
Legislative Council| Party | MP | Vote on Cloning | Vote on Surrogacy |
| Independent |
Archer, Hon. Shelley |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
Baston, Hon. Ken |
Opposed cloning |
No vote recorded |
| A.L.P. |
Benson-Lisholm, Hon. Matthew |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
Cash, Hon. George |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Catania, Hon. Vincent |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Chance, Hon. Kim |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
Collier, Hon. Peter |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Dermer, Hon. Ed |
Opposed cloning |
Opposed surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
Donaldson, Hon. Bruce |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Doust, Hon. Kate |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| National Party |
Duncan, Hon. Wendy |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Ellery, Hon. Sue |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
Ellis, Hon. Brian |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
Faragher, Hon. Donna |
Opposed cloning |
Opposed surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Farina, Hon. Adele |
Supported cloning |
No vote recorded |
| Liberal Party |
Fels, Hon. Anthony |
Opposed cloning |
Opposed surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Ford, Hon. Jon |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Giffard, Hon. Graham |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Griffiths, Hon. Nick |
No vote recorded |
No vote recorded |
| Liberal Party |
Hallett, Hon. Nigel |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
Halligan, Hon. Ray |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
House, Hon. Barry |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Greens WA |
Llewellyn, Hon. Paul |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
McSweeney, Hon. Robyn |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Mills, Hon. Sheila |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
Moore, Hon. Norman |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
Morton, Hon. Helen |
Opposed cloning |
Opposed surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
O'Brien, Hon. Simon |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Pham, Hon. Batong |
Opposed cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Ravlich, Hon. Ljiljanna |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Liberal Party |
Scott, Hon. Barbara |
Opposed cloning |
Opposed surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Talbot, Hon. Sally |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| A.L.P. |
Travers, Hon. Ken |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
| Greens WA |
Watson, Hon. Giz |
Supported cloning |
Supported surrogacy |
Prostitution - How did your local MP vote?
Large numbers of West Australians voiced concern about the Prostitution Bill earlier this year. This controversial legislation passed by just one vote after independent Legislative Council Member Shelly Archer supported it at the last minute. Labor Members of Parliament voted on party lines, meaning all their members supported the bill. The Liberal Party took a united stand against it. Below is a list of how independents and minor parties voted. Legislative Assembly - Minor Parties & Independents| Electorate | Party | MP | Vote on Prostitution |
| Alfred Cove |
Independent Liberal |
Wollard, Dr Janet |
Opposed prostitution |
| Avon |
National Party |
Trenorden, Mr Max |
Opposed prostitution |
| Churchlands |
Independent |
Constable, Dr Elizabeth |
Opposed prostitution |
| Greenough |
National Party |
Woodhams, Mr Grant |
No vote recorded |
| Leschenault |
Independent |
Barron-Sullivan, Mr Dan |
Opposed prostitution |
| Merredin |
National Party |
Grylls, Mr John |
Paired |
| Murchison-Eyre |
Independent |
Bowler, Mr John |
No vote recorded |
| Nedlands |
Independent |
Walker, Ms Sue |
Opposed prostitution |
| Stirling |
National Party |
Redman, Mr Donald |
Opposed prostitution |
| Yokine |
Independent |
Kucera, Mr Bob |
Supported prostitution |
Legislative Council - Minor Parties & Independents| Party | MP | Vote on Prostitution |
| Independent |
Archer, Hon. Shelley |
Paired although supported the bill |
| National Party |
Duncan, Hon. Wendy |
Opposed prostitution |
| Greens WA |
Llewellyn, Hon. Paul |
Supported prostitution |
| Greens WA |
Watson, Hon. Giz |
Supported prostitution |
|